Well, I don’t want to burst your bubble, but most organic farming is corporate.
Cargill might be one of the largest as far as grains go.
Actually you could think of Corporate farming as being older than America with most of the early settlements (which later became states) started as corporate farms.
The only other reasons for starting settlements were for extracting raw materials. Mining, fishing or logging count as resource extraction, but really are part of the same colonial systems as the plantations were.
Early American development depended on the British and other European Enpires for access to world markets.
The plantation system certainly was corporate, and included Rice in South Carolina, cotton, wheat and tobacco.
South Carolina at one time was the world’s largest single rice producer. For a while Virgina collected taxes in tobacco and counted it as currency.
America has continued the plantation scheme with other countries. Think Rubber plantations up until the 1970s when synthetics replaced most raw rubber needs.
Or the Sugar plantations,
Bananas,
I think the idea of a plantation economy should be expanded to include corporate farming as practiced in the wheatlands. Corporate farms actually operate as plantations.
Corporate is a description of ownership and management rather than a description of the style of farming. We take out corporation status to provide for certain tax benefits, some strategies for keeping family control instead of dividing the farm up to individuals who will ultimately sell their part to outsiders.
There is of course the risk that the corporation may cause complete loss of family control.
But what many people think of when they use the term corporate farming is otherwise known as vertical integration.. a company that produces inputs for farming leases or buys large tracts of land and grows crops using their inputs, a buyer of farm products may do the same… cutting out the middle man, the farm entrepreneur.
But the same objective is often accomplished by simply buying farm outputs on forward contracts. We see a difference here, that the farm entrepreneur is still involved. But as the buying corporation starts to want better control of what they will be processing, they start providing a lot of technical guidance to the farm operator.
Along with providing that technical guidance comes a quickly developing corporate culture of farming expertise. The corporation does learn enough to do a really good job without the input of the farm operator. The corporation is also in a great position to do the best in marketing, particularly its own farm products, because it does plan and execute the whole process.
Corporation per se does allow for a management structure that intends to put into various roles people qualified to do the role. There is not the same tendency we see in one-person operations for tasks to be done by people much better qualified to do something else. Even such mundane questions as who negotiates purchases of inputs and machinery, who takes the time to study market trends, who sets up the accounting and record keeping… Corporations work at all because they work at choosing the right person for the role.
This is not to say that an individual entrepreneur can not build a non-corporate structure that manages personnel well. But most businesses that grow from one-man operations do not ever make that leap.
Even the farmer who has a great grasp of the science of agriculture rarely has the overall skills needed to grow a business in a non-corporate style, so that it has the business strength to prosper and to carry on into the third generation.
So, Organic farms, the people using the certified organic brand, and the processors / packers of Certified Organic products also have a reason to rationalize their operations, gain top to bottom control so that they can produce a product that is as consistent as possible withing the constraints of ORGANIC RULES.
But like non-organic producers/processors, they have to build an organization that does its management in a reliable consistent way, a corporate way, if they hope to achieve those results.
The same processes of vertical integration, transfer of expertise and finally replacement of the organic farm entrepreneur with a staff appointment will be observed, not just because it is a corporation taking control, but because we see advantages of better control, even though it destroys our original personal strategies.